I was elated to be invited back for a second term as a Bisto Book of the Year judge – and after months of turning pages, munching sandwiches and hours of debate, my second chance as a judge for the Bisto Book of the Year is at an end.
So what did I learn this time round?
It is still far easier to criticise a judges decision from the outside.
Last year I wrote about the omissions on the shortlist. As I did the year before. And I’ll do the same this time round too. What is popular does not always make the shortlist. I would like to see that change but the awards have specific criteria that lay out how books are to be judged – and literary merit doesn’t always mean popularity. Publishing a longlist may still be an answer but this isn’t an award for what sells or what kids read most – it goes for the best written.
Celebrating Irish writing doesn’t mean celebratin Irish publishing.
There are only 3 books from Irish publishers on the shortlist – and two of those are in Irish. Maybe with the advent of Little Island there will be more home-grown names shortlisted next year – but while the awards celebrate Irish illustration and writing there wasn’t as much to celebrate in Irish children’s publishing.
Talking about a book you love is much harder than one you don’t.
This is still true from last year. I found it far more difficult to defend a book I liked than a book I didn’t. There are still only so many times you can say ‘this book is indefinable’ and ‘worthy winner’.
Junior juries can only be a good thing.
This year the awards are a little bit different. CBI, not content with just having regular judging (not that there is anything wrong with the charming, handsome and witty judges), have set up a series of Junior Juries around the country. Running alongside the shadowing scheme from previous years the Junior Juries panel will award their own prize for Bisto Book of the Year. I can’t wait to see who they choose!
The judges.
Apart from reading so many stories – the most enjoyable aspect of the awards was meeting the other judges. Sharing ideas, stories and jokes with the six other judges (as well as Maire and Aoife) was as rewarding as the judging. Thanks to Jennifer Carpenter, Valerie Coughlan, Luke Markey, Ríona Nic Congáil, Eileen Phelan and Juliette Saumande, Maire Uí Mhaicín and Aoife Murray for a fascinating and eye opening few months.
Not long to go before the winners are announced!